Bully Sticks vs Rawhide: Which One is Best for Your Dog?

bully sticks vs rawhide

There is a lot of debate over what chewy is the best option for your dog’s health and enjoyment. Bully sticks and rawhide are both great choices for keeping your canine occupied and happy. But which one is better? 

Choosing between the two for your pup can depend on many things. Do you have a small dog or a big dog? Do they have sensitive teeth or digestion issues? Does your dog tend to swallow treats whole? 

Like any product, both options have benefits and drawbacks. Today we will review six different products that are popular among dogs and their humans.

Bully Sticks vs Rawhide

Bully sticks come from the pizzle of the bull, which is muscle tissue. Muscle tissue is much easier for dogs to digest, and it has a great natural flavor they’ll love. Bully sticks are becoming increasingly popular due to their natural, chemical-free quality.

Rawhide chews are from the hide or skin of the animal before the tanning process occurs. Many rawhides include harsh chemical washes to achieve the final look and texture. 

However, there are still plenty of all-natural rawhide options available for your pup. Rawhide treats also remain the most affordable of the two.

The odds are that your four-legged friend likes both of these popular treats, but they probably aren’t as concerned about the health facts as you are. A healthy diet equals a happy dog.

The final decision will ultimately depend on your dog’s preferences, but we will cover the pros and cons of both. And, yes, we will declare an overall winner! Besides your dog, that is.

Let’s take a look at the competition.

Bully Sticks

1. Redbarn Bully Stick 7″ Dog Treat

Redbarn Bully Stick 7" Dog Treat

Redbarn provides a well-rounded bully stick. Great for heavy chewers. They have a slow-roasted flavor and natural ingredients.

You can purchase these in a pack of one, three, or six. If you prefer to buy in bulk they also have an option to buy a case of thirty-five.

Redbarn says their product is ideal for small, medium, and large dogs in all breeds.

Customer reviews mention they are great for teething puppies and strong chewers.

Flavor: Natural

Nutrition info: 

  • 100% beef pizzle
  • Crude Protein – 80.0% min
  • Crude Fat – 1.0% min
  • Crude Fiber – 1.0% max
  • Moisture – 18.0% max

PROS

  • Easily digestible
  • Promotes healthy teeth and gums
  • Good for teething puppies

CONS

  • Sizing variations
  • Not ideal for aggressive chewers

2. Best Bully Sticks Thick 6″ Bully Sticks Dog Treats

Best Bully Sticks Thick 6" Bully Sticks Dog Treats

Best Bully Sticks are the number one online bully stick brand because their product is hand inspected for quality and consistency. These bully sticks are up 50 percent thicker than competing brands.

These six-inch chew treats come in a package of 18 to last you a fair amount of time.

Best Bully Sticks say their product is ideal for small and medium-sized breeds.

Customer reviews mention high quality, easy on sensitive teeth, and can occupy heavy chewers for a decent amount of time. While the smell is more intense than other products, the durability makes it worth it.

Flavor: Natural

Nutrition info:

  • Free-range Brazilian cattle
  • Additive-free
  • Chemical-free
  • Preservative-free
  • Crude Protein – 86.4% min
  • Crude Fat – 3.2% min
  • Crude Fiber – 0.5% min
  • Moisture – 10.8% max

PROS

  • Easily digestible
  • Promotes healthy teeth and gums
  • Thicker than other brands

CONS

  • Not for large dogs
  • More expensive than other brands
  • Strong odor

3. GigaBite Odor-Free Bully Sticks Dog Treats

 GigaBite Odor-Free Bully Sticks Dog Treats

GigaBite Bully Sticks have high marks for their odor-free quality, rare to find in a dog treat. They will also keep your floors and furniture free of the dreaded chew toy stains.

These treats are available in two different sizes; 6 inches and 12 inches. The 6-inch option comes in a package of approximately 10 sticks. In comparison, the 12-inch bully sticks include about 7 sticks.

GigaBite says their product is ideal for small, medium, and large dogs of all breeds.

Customer reviews mention the surprising longevity of these bully sticks. Perfect for small and medium-sized chewers.

Flavor: Natural

Nutritional info:

  • 100% pizzle
  • FDA and USDA-approved
  • Hormone-free
  • Preservative-free
  • Chemical-free

PROS

  • Easily digestible
  • Promotes healthy teeth and gums
  • No odor
  • Won’t leave stains

CONS

  • Size variation per package
  • Not ideal for aggressive chewers

4. Vital Essentials Bully Sticks Freeze-Dried Raw Dog Treats

Vital Essentials Bully Sticks Freeze-Dried Raw Dog Treats

Vital Essentials bully sticks come packed with extra flavor because they freeze-dry the treats for 48 hours before packaging them.

This bag of treats is sold by weight instead of quantity, so the value is consistent. You will receive a 1.7 oz bag of bully sticks that are made entirely in the USA.

This brand says their product is ideal for small, medium, and large dogs of all breeds.

Customer reviews mention all breeds and sizes loving these organic treats—even older pups with sensitive teeth.

See Related Topic: Pig Ears vs Rawhide: Which is the Best One?

Flavor: Natural

Nutritional info: 

  • USDA beef pizzle
  • Grain-free
  • Gluten-free
  • Crude Protein – 62.0% min
  • Crude Fat – 9.0% min
  • Crude Fiber – 5.0% max
  • Moisture – 8.0% max

PROS

  • Easily digestible
  • Promotes healthy teeth and gums
  • Extra intense flavor
  • More nutrients than other brands
  • Made in the USA

CONS

  • Not as long-lasting
  • Odor

Rawhide Chews

1. PetAg Rawhide Brand Natural Beef Hides Chips Dog Treats

 PetAg Rawhide Brand Natural Beef Hides Chips Dog Treats

PetAg makes flavorful, chewy treats without using harsh chemicals, which means stain-free enjoyment for you and your dog.

Rawhide chips are a fantastic value because they come in a 32 oz package, giving you a great bang for your buck.

This product says it’s ideal for small, medium, and large dogs of all breeds.

Customer reviews mention how good they are for pups with sensitive stomachs. They are also great for keeping teeth clean.

Flavor: Natural

Nutritional info:

  • 100% Brazillian beef rawhide
  • Free-range,
  • Antibiotic-free
  • Hormone-free

PROS

  • Helps clean teeth and gums
  • No harsh chemicals
  • Won’t leave stains
  • Good for sensitive stomachs

CONS

  • Not much nutrition
  • Choking hazard

2. Castor & Pollux Good Buddy USA Rawhide Dog Bone

Castor & Pollux Good Buddy USA Rawhide Dog Bone

What puppy can resist a classic dog bone? Especially if it’s chicken flavor. The Castor & Pollux bone is a great chew toy that can double as an excuse to play fetch with your furry friend.

You can purchase this rawhide bone in four different sizes to suit the chewing preferences of your dog. It comes in small, medium, large, and extra-large.

The size options make this bone ideal for dogs of all breeds and sizes.

Customer reviews mention the lasting ability even with larger dogs. They are also a fun way to keep your dog active by playing fetch.

Flavor: chicken

Nutritional info:

  • USA beef rawhide 
  • Natural chicken flavor.
  • Wheat-free
  • Soy-free
  • Corn-free

PROS

  • Helps clean teeth and gums
  • Four different sized options
  • Good price value
  • Long-lasting

CONS

  • Odor
  • Not much nutrition

3. Pure & Simple Pet Rawhide Retriever Roll

Pure & Simple Pet Rawhide Retriever Roll

Pure & Simple Pet rawhide rolls pride themselves on being more digestible than other rawhide chewies. Made from only one ingredient and the rolled-up design adds extra chewing time for your pup.

These treats are eight inches long, and you can purchase them in a pack of one, three, or fifteen. Your dog will agree that more is better when it comes to treats.

Because of the size of this rawhide roll, it is best for large breeds or aggressive chewers.

Customer reviews mention these rawhide rolls will satisfy even the pickiest of large dogs. And they can last for up to a week depending on the chewing aggression. 

See Related Topic: The Himalayan Dog Chew Review

Flavor: Natural

Nutritional info:

  • 100% American Beef-Hide
  • Crude Protein – 75.0% min
  • Crude Fat – 1.0% min
  • Crude Fiber – 3.5% max
  • Moisture – 16.0% max

PROS

    • Great for bigger dogs
    • Made from one ingredient
    • Easily digestible
    • Promotes healthy teeth and gums

CONS

  • Not ideal for small dogs
  • The larger pack is pricey

The Winner Of Today’s Review: Bully Sticks!

It all boils down to ingredients. Bully sticks are much more digestible for your dog than rawhide because they are made of muscle tissue. 

Easy digestion means less risk of upset stomach, intestine blockages, and choking hazards. Rawhide is easier for your pup to break down into small sharp pieces, creating choking hazards. This is why some dog owners choose to avoid it.

Just because rawhide chews didn’t win does not mean all of them are bad for your canine buddy. There are three wonderful options listed above and many more without harmful chemical washes.

Every doggo is different, and the same goes for bully sticks and rawhides. Trial and error are what every dog owner goes through when searching for the perfect chew treat. But if you don’t want to risk any digestion issues, it may be best to try out bully sticks.

Chewy.com has many more options to choose from if you didn’t see a good fit in this article. It’s not very unlikely your dog will be upset about test tasting either way. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *